HomeBusinessLewisham residents split over paused shopping centre homes plan

Lewisham residents split over paused shopping centre homes plan

Published at 9:30am

Residents in Lewisham are split over the paused redevelopment of the borough’s shopping centre — some backing the council’s demand for more social housing, others mourning a lost opportunity.

Developer Landsec said last month that it was deprioritising the billion-pound scheme to rebuild Lewisham Shopping Centre, blaming economic conditions and the council’s wish for more social homes in the plans.

The scheme would have delivered 1,744 homes, student accommodation and a new shopping centre. Of the homes, 98 were earmarked for social rent and 231 classed as affordable, alongside 661 student rooms and a 23-storey co-living block with 445 homes.

Those figures sit at the heart of the row. The 98 social-rent homes amount to just 5.6% of the 1,744 proposed, and the 231 affordable homes add another 13.2% — 329 affordable homes in all, or 18.9% of the total, leaving 1,415 at full market rates. It is that balance, or lack of it, that divided opinion on the streets around the centre this week.

A council that changed hands

The scheme was given the go-ahead by Lewisham Council’s Labour administration in October 2025. But the Green Party took control at the local elections in May 2026 and asked the developer for more social housing.

Landsec said that desire, combined with what it called “exceptionally challenging economic conditions”, meant it could no longer make the project work. The redevelopment was put on hold in October, and the developer walked away from the scheme after the council’s new leadership set out its position.

One local man told reporters the council’s stance was “completely understandable”. “There’s so little housing, particularly social housing, involved in the plans,” he said. “I think the council has really underplayed the amount of social housing we need in this area. So I kind of understand the new council’s point of view on this one.”

Others saw it differently. One woman called Landsec’s decision a “real shame”. “It’s a really big opportunity,” she said. “It’s a balance, because some social housing that gets built is better than no social housing.” A Greenwich resident said: “I just kind of feel like they’ve missed an opportunity.”

The mayor’s case

Liam Shrivastava, the mayor of Lewisham, said the council wanted to see “genuinely affordable housing coming forward”. “We’re in the middle of a housing crisis,” he said. “We’ve got over 11,000 people on the housing waiting list, we’ve got a growing number of families in temporary accommodation.”

“We want to see more affordable homes, but we’ve actually got to think about the viability of these schemes and what they can deliver,” he added. He said the council wanted financial backing from the government to “build our own homes… and get the money that we need to be able to do that.”

The demand is stark. Charlie Berry, policy manager at the housing charity Shelter, said London had more than 300,000 households on the social housing waiting list. “The need is just so urgent right across London,” she said.

The other side of the argument

Not everyone agrees that holding out for more affordable homes is the right call. Silvia Andreoletti, from the Adam Smith Institute think tank, said any affordable homes were better than none.

“London has a housing crisis, everyone knows that. It’s really expensive to live in London,” she said. “But the way to solve that housing crisis isn’t to put more regulations and more restrictions on developers because that means they just won’t build.”

“It’s basic economics, 35% of 0 is 0, 20% of any number is far better,” she said. “Any houses are better than no houses, because that means more houses to go around for everyone, and everyone can afford it a little bit more.”

The 35% figure refers to the affordable-homes quota for new developments in the capital, cut to 20% by the government and the mayor of London in 2025.

Landsec said that while it would “focus on other residential projects”, it remained committed to working with Lewisham Council on a regeneration scheme for the centre, and would keep operating and investing in the existing building.

Lewisham is not alone: British Land has also put the next phase of its Canada Water development on hold, in another sign of the pressure on large housing projects across the capital.

For now, the shopping centre stays as it is — and the argument over what should replace it, and how much of it ordinary Londoners could afford, goes on.

James Carter
James Carter
James Carter is the editor of London Streets, covering breaking news and developing stories across the capital. He leads the site's day-to-day news coverage so Londoners never miss what matters.
RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular