A 126-year-old plane tree in Stroud Green has been saved after Haringey Council confirmed it will not be removed.
The plane tree in Oakfield Road was the subject of a petition, vigils and a legal battle after it was threatened with being felled.
The case stemmed from a 2022 claim with Allianz and Aviva — insurers of two homes in Oakfield Road — which blamed the tree for causing subsidence.
They wanted Haringey Council to cut it down, but campaign group Haringey Tree Protectors argued that the tree was not the primary cause of the subsidence and called for engineering solutions, such as underpinning, instead of felling.
Campaigners held vigils, launched petitions and legal challenges to stop the tree from being removed, and the Financial Ombudsman twice ruled that insurers should pay to underpin the affected house.
They eventually agreed, but fearing there was still a statutory liability, Haringey Council carried out a consultation in 2025 on a proposal to remove the tree.
The authority received 732 objections and has now said the tree will remain and be managed in line with other plane trees on the street — being pollarded every two years.
The disputed property has now been sold and the insurance claim clarified, which has removed any council liability.
Cllr Gio Iozzi, cabinet member for climate action and transport, who was among the protestors fighting to save the tree, said: “I am proud to have stood with my fellow residents to protect the Oakfield Road Tree from the axe – this is a victory for every person who campaigned.”
He added: “Mature trees are essential public health infrastructure — existing cooling systems that we need as the droughts and floods in our cities only increase. Canopy means good health.”
“I will continue to lobby government and to raise awareness of an insurance system that blames healthy trees when we need them more than ever.”
“Today, I am focusing my time on making sure everything Haringey Council does protects trees, restores nature, and fights the climate crisis.”
The row drew national attention when Haringey Council took “possession” of the tree, then put up scaffolding and paid security staff to guard it from protestors.
Haringey Tree Protectors, which was formed by residents to monitor and protect trees and green spaces across the borough, say the case spotlights the issue of subsidence in London’s clay soil, where many late Victorian and Edwardian houses with shallow foundations are increasingly affected by ground movement during hot, dry summers.
The decision is a victory for the campaigners, but it also highlights a wider tension facing London boroughs. As summers get hotter and drier, subsidence claims linked to trees are becoming more common, and councils must weigh the cost of engineering solutions against the loss of mature trees that cool streets, clean the air and support wildlife.
Lewisham Council is consulting on a clean-up of its high streets, and two Croydon parks are set for transformation with new cafés and community hubs.

