HomeTransportPutney to Fulham 424 bus cut to every 40 minutes — and...

Putney to Fulham 424 bus cut to every 40 minutes — and walking is now faster

Published at 8:17am

Transport for London has cut the 424 bus between Putney Heath and Fulham to just one every 40 minutes, after a ten-month wait for a decision that leaves passengers with fewer buses than they had — and further from the half-hourly service they asked for.

The route, which runs from the Green Man on Putney Heath to Stevenage Road by Fulham FC, currently comes around every 35 minutes. Under the new timetable it will come every 40. Residents who answered TfL’s consultation had asked for a bus every 30 minutes or better.

It is a cut that makes the bus slower than walking for most journeys on the route. End to end, the 424 takes an hour and two minutes. The same trip on foot takes 41. That is because the bus winds through 7.6 miles of Putney and Fulham to reach a destination just 2.1 miles away.

Miss one by a minute and the maths gets worse. Comparing every possible journey between two stops on the route — all 676 of them — walking beats waiting for the next bus 96 per cent of the time, and every single time if you have just watched one pull away. From the top of Putney Hill to Fulham Broadway, a passenger who has just missed the 424 would arrive more than half an hour earlier by walking than by waiting.

The bus does win when it is already at the stop — then it is quicker on 488 of the 676 journeys. Its best run is Carslake Road to Sainsbury’s in Sands End: 29 minutes on board against a 57-minute walk. Its worst is Fulham FC to Putney Bridge station: 45 minutes on the bus, 18 on foot. The bus is not slow when it is moving — just over 7mph against 3mph on foot. It loses because it goes the long way round, and because the next one is so long in coming.

Who the cut hits hardest

For many of the people who rely on the 424, walking two miles is not an option. Nearly three in ten of its weekday passengers are older people travelling on a Freedom Pass, and nearly one in 20 more use a disabled person’s pass, according to TfL’s own figures.

That was the top worry in TfL’s consultation, raised in 82 comments. People who use the Sands End Community Centre told TfL many of them are over 65 or have mobility problems, and rely on the 424 several times a week to get there. For them there is no race with the bus — just a wait of up to 39 minutes. There is no 424 on a Sunday, and the last bus of the day leaves the Green Man at 7.10pm.

Passengers also told TfL they were worried about long waits and missed connections. TfL’s written response, in full, was: “Noted.”

Why TfL says it is doing it

TfL says cutting the service to a bus every 40 minutes “will allow for a more reliable service while still giving adequate value for money”. It describes the change as “slightly revised frequencies”.

Reliability has been the 424’s long-running problem. The route has missed TfL’s punctuality target in every period for two years, with its latest score at 60.5 per cent against a target of 78. A year ago TfL blamed congestion on Putney High Street and proposed splitting the route in two — the 424 shortened to run between Putney Heath and Putney High Street every 45 minutes, with a new 454 covering Putney Bridge to Fulham.

More than two in three of those who answered TfL’s consultation — 168 of 248 — said splitting the route would make things worse for them, and most called a 45-minute frequency “unworkable”. TfL has now dropped the split and kept the route whole. But the frequency it settled on, every 40 minutes, is still fewer buses than passengers already had.

Putney MP Fleur Anderson wrote to the Deputy Mayor for Transport, Seb Dance, two days before TfL’s decision, saying the 424 “should be retained in its current form”. She objected that the plans would “reduce the frequency of the service on the Putney section of the route”.

What happens next

TfL has not said when the 40-minute timetable becomes permanent. It says new electric buses will arrive “in due course”, and that its monitoring will continue “to ensure services match passenger demand”.

Passengers unhappy with the decision can complain to TfL through its online contact form, and if they are unhappy with the answer, London TravelWatch, the independent transport watchdog, hears appeals against TfL. After that, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman can consider complaints about bus routes. Fleur Anderson MP, who has already raised the 424 with the Deputy Mayor, can be contacted at fleur.anderson.mp@parliament.uk, and Leonie Cooper, the London Assembly Member for Merton and Wandsworth, at leonie.cooper@london.gov.uk.

It comes in a busy week for TfL passengers, with Santander Cycles facing a four-day shutdown as a new app rolls out. TfL is also pressing ahead with a £200,000 plan to move the crossing at Putney Bridge to cut traffic queues, while in Richmond councillors have refused plans to speed up the SL7 and 285 buses.

The 424 at a glance

Route: Putney Heath (Green Man) to Fulham (Stevenage Road / Fulham Football Club), via Putney Hill, Putney station, Putney Bridge, Fulham Broadway and Sands End. Operator: London General. Stops: 27. Frequency: every 40 minutes under the new timetable, down from every 35. Hours: Monday to Saturday, first bus around 6.30am, last bus 7.10pm from the Green Man. No Sunday service.

Sophie Turner
Sophie Turner
Sophie Turner covers transport, major developments, education and council affairs for London Streets.
RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular