A former Metropolitan Police detective gave conflicting accounts about the death of his wife in a hotel room in Barbados, a BBC Panorama investigation has found, and the Met never sent detectives to the island to investigate.
Warren Arter, 54, a former detective inspector, told different versions of what happened to his wife Rebekah, 47, who died in a hotel room in Barbados in June 2024. Her family are speaking publicly for the first time about her death.
Arter told a close friend of Rebekah’s that she had “choked” or that she had collapsed and banged her head. He told her brother Andrew that she had fallen near a chest of drawers — although Andrew said her body was some distance from the drawers. He later said he had woken up to find Rebekah dead in bed next to him.
“He lied to us all,” Andrew said.
The Metropolitan Police’s own record of a call to a Gold Command officer in London, four days after Rebekah’s death, showed Arter initially said he had not been drinking and had not taken drugs, despite telling the coroner he had seen her take drugs.
Barbados police did not secure the hotel room as a crime scene or take vital forensic evidence from it, the investigation found. Rebekah’s organs were removed in the mortuary and later returned to the UK in plastic bags.
The family asked the Met to send detectives to Barbados to investigate. The force did not do so, and Arter was never interviewed by the Met about Rebekah’s death, despite being a serving police officer at the time.
John Gittins, the senior coroner for East Riding of Yorkshire and Hull, recorded an open verdict, meaning the evidence did not establish how Rebekah died. He concluded her death likely involved intoxication and said unlawful killing could not be ruled out.
Arter was arrested at Heathrow Airport on his return to the UK and held at HMP Wandsworth, where he took his own life days later. He had been arrested on suspicion of murder.
The investigation, by Panorama, is to be broadcast on BBC One on Tuesday 17 November at 8pm under the title Panorama: The Detective, the Death and the Lies.
A career that ended in dismissal
Arter met Rebekah in 2006, after she reported domestic abuse by a former partner. Three years later, he was placed in charge of a unit in south-east London investigating rape cases.
He was suspended from duty in 2021 after being accused of sexually assaulting a colleague. He remained suspended on full pay for almost two years before he was dismissed in 2023, after being found to have committed gross misconduct for taking drugs.
An investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct found that Arter had sexually assaulted eight women. He was never convicted of a criminal offence, despite being arrested on suspicion of rape.
Rebekah’s son Elliot said: “I just want to know what happened to my mum.” Her son Harris said: “I don’t think I’ll ever get over it.”
Metropolitan Police Commander Simon Messinger said: “Our thoughts at this time are with Rebekah Arter’s family and loved ones.” He added: “We would urge any victim survivors of rape and sexual offences – no matter how long ago a crime may have taken place – to come forward and report it to us.”
The case raises serious questions about how the Met handled the death of a serving officer’s wife abroad — and about the force’s failure to investigate one of its own. The family had asked for detectives to be sent to Barbados. Instead, no Met officer was ever sent, and Arter was never questioned by his own force about what happened in that hotel room.
The Met has faced repeated questions over its handling of officers accused of sexual offences. A separate investigation into non-recent serious sexual offence allegations remains open, while the force has appealed for information after the death of Thomas Oduro in Lordship Lane.

